Kalvin Phillips faced a setback after a brief positive spell. Although he showcased potential by starting in the Champions League and scoring his first goal for Manchester City, he returned to his usual substitute role without playing three days later.
During City’s loss to Palace, coach Pep Guardiola opted for Rodri alongside youngster Rico Lewis instead of Phillips. Lewis seized the opportunity, operating further forward and not only scoring but also setting up a goal the previous week.
Despite Guardiola’s doubts about Phillips fitting into the system, the player struggled to prove him wrong in the Champions League match in Belgrade, despite confidently taking a penalty. His subdued celebration after the win against Red Star indicated his awareness that this might not be enough to halt any momentum driving him to depart in January.
Although Newcastle has shown interest in the England international, Eddie Howe seems to steer his team away, despite their need for a holding midfielder due to Sandro Tonali’s suspension. City may suffer if Phillips joins a Premier League rival, potentially bolstering their strength at a crucial stage in the title race.
City remains focused on claiming the title but risks granting Newcastle an advantage, affecting their aspirations. While currently occupying the fourth spot, they might drop further by their next game, realizing that keeping an eye on rivals is key to reclaiming a top-four position.
There are concerns for Phillips’ future. Guardiola suggests retaining him if he stays, yet his playing opportunities seem limited, especially with a packed schedule post-Christmas. To secure a place in England’s Euro 2024 squad, Phillips acknowledges the necessity for consistent playtime.
A move to Juventus could revitalize Phillips’ career, offering a fresh start away from Premier League scrutiny and City’s comparisons. There, he could concentrate on competing for the Serie A title without European distractions and secure regular playing time. Staying in the Premier League would subject him to intense fan and media scrutiny, following the challenges he faced at City.
Whether Juventus’s interest in Italy is genuine or merely speculative remains to be seen. Nonetheless, temporarily leaving the Premier League could potentially benefit Phillips and City in the long run.
