A year ago, Manchester City’s goalkeeper and defense were so dependable that fans had a song celebrating their defenders:
Ake and Ederson. Walker and the Japanese. Dias Ruben. John Stones.
The goalkeeper was unbeatable, delivering a Champions League-winning performance in Istanbul, justifying his manager’s unwavering trust.
Stones redefined the center-back role by moving into midfield. Nathan Ake ended City’s long search for a solid left-back. Manu Akanji, signed for a bargain £14 million, filled in wherever needed.
After their treble triumph, Kyle Walker was the only uncertainty. Having been left out of the championship game and considering a move to Bayern Munich, he chose to sign a new deal, became captain, and made more starts than any other defender during the season.
Now 34, Walker admits his playing time might decrease in future seasons, raising questions about the right-back position’s future. Stones had to fight hard to regain his first-team spot after being left out during the run-in.
Even Dias’s place wasn’t secure. Strong performances by newcomer Josko Gvardiol and consistent showings by Ake and Akanji in the latter part of the season pushed him out of the team. Guardiola maintained his philosophy that a well-performing player keeps their spot.
Ederson has been linked with a move, and backup goalkeeper Stefan Ortega could seek more playing time elsewhere this summer.
In the first of three parts of our squad assessment, we examine each goalkeeper and defender’s position after the 2023–2024 season and what they need to do to improve for the next season:
Possible Departures
First, the bad news. Stefan Ortega, after a series of strong performances, hinted at a possible departure this summer. Although he wants more playing time, Pep Guardiola has consistently assured him he’d remain the number two keeper next season.
With a second child on the way, Ortega’s family needs will influence his decision, but he admitted last week that no offers compare to what City can provide. Despite rumors of a move to Saudi Arabia, Guardiola and City want Ederson to stay.
Sergio Gomez, who played just six Premier League games for a total of 47 minutes this season, is the only defender likely to leave.
At 26, with two years left on his contract, he will likely seek a permanent or loan move for more playing time. Currently fifth choice at left-back, his prospects won’t improve next year.
