Phillips supported Pep’s comments as he made his Champions League debut for City, his sixth appearance overall. Despite playing in certain games of less importance or when resting Rodri was crucial, Phillips, who Guardiola previously apologized to for not featuring enough, was given a start in Serbia.
The match wasn’t an opportunity for Phillips to prove Guardiola wrong; rather, it reinforced Guardiola’s view. Kovacic was also positioned in a deeper role to support Phillips, but it didn’t bring out a composed performance from him.
He often lost possession, leading to opposition counter-attacks and even received a yellow card clumsily. Even though he scored a penalty, his celebration mirrored his perceived status within the teamβminimal enthusiasm. His standing doesn’t seem to have improved, considering Kovacic’s solidity and Nunes’ promising display. While Phillips needs regular games to prove himself, it seems unlikely at City, and he awaits January to make his mark.
Hamilton, a young talent from the academy, made an impressive debut in Belgrade, netting a spectacular goal that thrilled the traveling City fans. He exhibited energy throughout the game, contributing significantly late on, earning a decisive penalty.
Despite previously warming the bench under Guardiola, he demonstrated what City had been lacking. Coined a “street footballer” by his academy mentors, he displayed that style in Belgrade, suggesting a bright future. His impressive debut might ensure more chances in the future, making him the standout at Red Star.
City’s Belgrade XI showcased five academy graduates, with Foden and Lewis being role models for the youngsters. Bobb, with a stunning debut goal and the Player of the Match accolade, showed adaptability to first-team football. Hamilton’s debut promises City a reliable right-wing option. Susoho, Hamilton, and Bobb’s presence indicates City’s commitment to nurturing local talents, winning hearts of supporters.
Nunes, part of Guardiola’s rotated Red Star lineup, played in a three-man midfield alongside Kovacic and Phillips. With Nunes in an advanced role, he displayed glimpses of his potential. His attacking intent was evident, although he missed an opportunity to score and adapted well to the inexperienced frontline. However, his performance highlighted the challenge of securing a place in City’s competitive midfield, where the likes of Silva, Foden, Alvarez, and De Bruyne dominate. While Guardiola recognizes Nunes’ importance, finding minutes in his preferred position could be challenging.
The left-back position remains a concern for City, with Gomez getting a rare start in that role against Red Star. Despite an average performance, it didn’t alter Guardiola’s viewpoint on Gomez’s long-term prospects. Similar to Phillips, Gomez seems to have limited opportunities for regular playtime, having featured in multiple positions this season.
With just a few games of lower significance available for these players, the established defenders will likely return for tougher fixtures. Gomez’s performance didn’t notably enhance his standing in the left-back hierarchy, where Ake and Gvardiol have also vied for chances.
